One of the greatest challenges in reading familiar biblical stories is that we know too much. We know where the story is going long before the biblical characters do; we know who will be born, who will inherit the promise, who will become the central figure of the next chapter, and because we know the ending so well, we don’t really think about the uncertainty through which the story actually unfolds. We stand at the end of the road looking backward and seeing it all in hindsight – while the biblical characters are still taking one uncertain step after another, unable to see what lies beyond the next bend.
Genesis 17 is one of those chapters where it’s good to forget, at least for a little while, everything we already know and to read it again—not through our own eyes, with Isaac already firmly established in our minds, but through the eyes of Abraham, who at the beginning of this chapter has never heard Isaac’s name and has no reason whatsoever to expect another son.
For us, Genesis 17 is the chapter in which Isaac is finally promised, and therefore we open it already waiting for him to appear. Abraham, however, had no such expectation. Thirteen years had passed since the birth of Ishmael—thirteen years during which Ishmael was not merely Abraham’s son, but his only son, thirteen years during which Abraham watched him grow from a baby into a young man and gradually learned to see the entire promised future through him. And why shouldn’t he? God had promised Abraham a multitude of descendants; Abraham now had a son; God Himself had met Hagar and spoken about Ishmael’s future; God Himself chose Ishmael’s amazing name. We know that another son is coming, but Abraham knows none of this, and if we want to hear Genesis 17 as Abraham heard it, we have to make the almost impossible effort of forgetting Isaac for a moment.
So, imagine that you have never read Genesis 18. Imagine that you know nothing about what will happen next. You are Abraham, ninety-nine years old, standing before the Lord after thirteen years during which Scripture records no word from God to you, and now, suddenly, God is speaking again. What do you hear? You hear about an everlasting covenant; you hear that you will become the father of many nations; you hear about kings who will come from you, about descendants and future generations, about a covenant that will endure forever. Again and again, the same themes return—covenant, descendants, nations, generations, future—and the horizon before Abraham keeps expanding with every sentence God speaks, while one simple fact remains unchanged throughout this entire magnificent revelation: Abraham still has only one son.
Every time God says, “your descendants,” whom would Abraham naturally picture? Every time God speaks about future generations, whose children and grandchildren would fill Abraham’s imagination? Every time Abraham hears about nations and kings who will come from him, through whom would he expect that extraordinary future to unfold? The answer is obvious: Ishmael. There is nobody else. Before Sarah is ever mentioned in connection with the promised son, before Isaac is even hinted at, the conversation is already dominated by the language of covenant and descendants. God’s promise keeps unfolding layer after layer, while the only piece of information that will completely transform Abraham’s world and understanding remains unspoken… till verse 16.
You might be asking what seemed like the obvious question: Why did God allow him to think that? Why didn’t God begin the conversation by saying, “Abraham, before I tell you anything else, Sarah will bear you a son”? Everything would immediately have become clear. Every subsequent promise about descendants, generations, nations, and covenant would automatically have been heard in the light of this future son. There would have been no room for misunderstanding, no possibility for Abraham to see the “wrong” picture.
But this is not how God chose to tell Abraham the story. Instead, He allowed Abraham to listen to almost the entire covenant revelation while naturally interpreting every promise through the only son he knew. Every God’s word was exactly what He intended to say, and yet He did not immediately correct the picture that Abraham was inevitably forming as he listened. In a sense, God allowed Abraham to hear the true words of the promise through the limited horizon available to him.
Then comes verse 16:
“I will bless her, and moreover, I will give you a son by her.”
One sentence—and suddenly the entire conversation has to be heard again.
It is not that God has changed His promise. Nothing God said in the previous verses has become less true; the covenant has not changed, the promise of descendants has not changed, the future nations and kings have not changed, and God’s intention has certainly not changed. What changes in one breathtaking moment is Abraham’s horizon. The words he heard correctly now have to be understood within a reality he could not possibly have imagined before God revealed it to him, and the future Abraham thought he already understood suddenly becomes much larger than the future he had been carrying in his heart.
Perhaps this is one of the masterpieces of Genesis: like Abraham, when we hear God’s words, we interpret them through the only reality available to us, and without even noticing what we are doing, we begin finishing God’s sentences for Him. Perhaps one of the greatest acts of divine patience is that God sometimes allows us to understand His words correctly but incompletely – like Abraham- until He is ready to reveal the rest of the sentence. He does not always begin by dismantling everything we think we know; every new revelation doesn’t mean that yesterday’s understanding was false; but sometimes yesterday’s understanding simply becomes too small for what God shows us today. Abraham’s confidence in God’s promise was not the problem. The problem was that he thought he already knew how this promise must be fulfilled.
And perhaps this is exactly what we continue to do. We hear, “I will provide,” and before God has finished speaking, we already know how. We hear, “I will bless,” and immediately we know through whom. We hear, “I will open a door,” and we have already decided which door it must be. We may sincerely believe God, trust His faithfulness, and hold firmly to His promise, while at the same time quietly filling in the blanks He Himself has deliberately left empty. Rarely do we notice that God has not yet reached the end of His sentence before we have supplied the ending ourselves.
Perhaps this is why Genesis 17 speaks so deeply to me. It reminds me that faith is not merely believing God’s promises; faith is also allowing God Himself to define the way those promises will be fulfilled. It means resisting the temptation to turn our interpretation into His promise, to confuse the picture in our imagination with the words He actually spoke, and to finish His sentences before He has finished speaking.
Probably, this is the deepest surprise hidden in this very familiar chapter. Before God reveals Isaac, He allows Abraham—and, if we read slowly enough, He allows us—to inhabit a smaller world for a little while, not necessarily because everything in that world is false, but because only after we have lived inside its boundaries can we fully experience the breathtaking moment when one sentence from God opens a door into a world we did not know existed.
I hope we will all remember Abraham standing before the Lord in Genesis 17, listening to promises he truly believed and quietly imagining a future God had not actually described. I hope we will always remember that God’s promises may be larger than our imagination, deeper than our expectations, and far more surprising than the future we have already imagined —and that what seems like the end of His sentence may sometimes be only a pause.
Perhaps the wisest response is not to finish God’s sentence at all, but simply to keep listening… until God does.
If you like the posts on this blog, you might enjoy my books, you can find them here: books. As always, I would be happy to provide more information (also, a teacher’s discount for new students) regarding our wonderful courses (juliab@eteachergroup.com)
